Indulge in the best, completely over-the-top cookies in New Jersey. The best cookies in NJ are far from your average. These can’t resist desserts are chewy, sweet, rich, decadent – and sometimes even filled or covered. Consider yourself a true dessert lover or cookie enthusiast? Then, these spots absolutely need to be on your list. Keep reading to learn about the best cookies in NJ that are completely over-the-top.

Stuffed Cookies

If over-the-top is what you’re looking for, you can’t go wrong with the best stuffed cookies in NJ. Fair warning – these are miles from your ordinary cookies. On the outside, they’re delicious, warm, and soft-baked. Inside, there’s a gooey center filled with a variety of incredible, mouthwatering flavors. The sweet taste, melt-in-your-mouth texture, bold pairings – it’s truly an unmatched, one-of-a-kind cookie experience. Certainly, try over-the-top stuffed cookies from the best dessert bakeries in NJ.

The BEST Chocolate Chip Cookies

You can find the most over-the-top, best, and biggest chocolate chip cookies in NJ. It’s fair to say that chocolate chip cookies are on everyone’s favorite dessert list. But the chocolate chip cookies at over-the-top bakeries in NJ are truly on another level. The best part? Our chocolate chip cookies are absolutely huge! It’s a chocolate or cookie lovers dream. But even though these cookies are big, don’t be surprised if you still want more than one. Definitely, you have to try the chocolate chip cookies at NJ’s most over-the-top dessert bakeries.

Birthday Cake Cookies

You can always indulge in delicious & over-the-top birthday cake cookies in NJ – it doesn’t even have to be your birthday! If we’re being honest, the best birthdays call for cake AND cookies. If you serve these delicious stuffed cookies at your B-Day party, it’s sure to be an absolute hit. These cookies are sweet, delicious, nostalgic, and always heavy on the sprinkles. Happy birthday to you! This year, try decadent B-Day cake cookies in NJ for your birthday – or the other 364 days of the year!

S’Mores Cookies

Or, satisfy your dessert cravings with amazing s’mores cookies from the best bakery in Montclair NJ. Is there anything more fun, memorable, and crowd-pleasing than s’mores? How about cookies? Everyone’s two favorite dessert flavors – expertly crafted into one. We know, you didn’t think it was possible for s’mores or cookies to get even better. Rich chocolate, gooey marshmallow, and crushed graham cracker – you won’t want to miss this. Surely, top-rated bakeries are known for the best s’mores cookies in NJ.

BONUS: Custom Cookie Cakes

For something truly over-the-top, order a custom cookie cake in NJ for your next special occasion. Enjoy the classic, soft, and chewy cookie taste – only as the cake for your next event. Get in touch with our custom cakes team – and we’ll help you choose the perfect size, frosting, flavor, decorations, and toppings. A cookie cake is the ultimate way to conclude your event with a unique, memorable, and over-the-top addition. Absolutely, get a cookie cake in NJ for your next over-the-top event.

Try the best cookies in New Jersey – beware these are totally over-the-top. Stuffed cookies are always a must-order from the best dessert places in NJ. These trendy spots are known for their classic – but huge – chocolate chip cookies too. For something different, ask for a birthday cake or s’mores cookie – you’ll see why they’re so popular after just one bite. Or for a celebration, let us design a custom cookie cake for you. Follow the points above to learn about the best cookies in NJ that are truly over-the-top.