Many local surveys agree that apple pie in New Jersey is an all time favorite. Accompanied with a classic scoop of vanilla ice cream, residents in NJ love their apple pie in the fall seasons and the middle of summer. However, everyone has their own opinion on the best pie. Whether it’s a relative’s secret recipe or a local bakery in North Jersey, you need some signals that you have found the best apple pie in NJ. Here’s some top signs that you have found the best.

Freshly Baked

Of course, one of the main signs that you have found the best apple pie in New Jersey is that it is freshly baked. The most delicious pies have not been sitting inside of a glass container for days on end. They are baked fresh in-house every morning so you always receive a moist slice. You can tell just from looking at a pie whether it was baked the same day or has been sitting since last week. The coloring of fresh-baked pies will be golden brown and the crust will look deliciously flaky. Plus, freshly baked apple pies give off the most warming smell that leaves dessert lovers drooling. If you have found a freshly baked pie from the best bakery Paramus NJ, you may have found the ultimate apple pie.

Irresistibly Buttery Crust

Another sign that you have found the best apple pie North Jersey has to offer is that it has an irresistibly buttery crust. A buttery crust is essential because it is always your last bite. You do not want to put your fork down feeling unsatisfied with that final mouthful. Instead, you want to wish that you had savored it a bit longer. To ensure that you have this experience, search for a pie with a golden brown crust. Assure that you can smell the sweet buttery scent before diving in as well. This is a tell-tale sign that you have found the best apple pie in the state.

Perfectly Sized

Additionally, perfect sizing is yet another sign that you have found the best apple pie New Jersey has to offer. Perfect sizing is important for dessert lovers who want to purchase pie for various occasions. The best apple pie will come in a big enough size to bring to your Thanksgiving dessert table. It will also come in the right size for just you and your family to enjoy after dinner. Some Rutherford NJ bakeries even offer mini apple pies so you can have a single serving as well. With plenty of sizing options, you never have to turn down the best apple pie in NJ. This is why perfect sizing is a tell-tale sign that you have found the ultimate pie.

One-Of-A-Kind Recipe

If you find a pie with a one-of-a-kind recipe, it is another sign that you have discovered the best apple pie in NJ. When you take a bite of the best pie in the state, you will know it immediately. The ingredients create a consistency, texture and taste that no other pie can offer. You will be amazed from the flaky crust all the way down to the unbelievable cinnamon filling. The uniqueness makes purchasing the pie worthwhile. Keep this sign in mind to ensure that you find the best apple pie in Bergen County NJ.

Filling In Every Bite

Furthermore, filling in every bite is a sign that you have found the best apple pie in Northern NJ. When you eat a sub-par slice of apple pie, you get full mouthfuls of just crust. After each one, you ask yourself “where is the filling?”. It is, after all, the best part of the entire dessert. Fortunately, the best apple pie gives you a mouthful of both crust and sweet, apple cinnamon filling in every bite. You will never be left wondering what you paid for. Instead, you will be left wanting another slice of ooey-gooey deliciousness. Thus, filling in every bite is a sign that you have found the ultimate slice of apple pie.

Apple pie is one of the most delicious desserts that you can find at the best bakeries in NJ. However, it can still be difficult to find the perfect slice. To do so, you need to look for specific signs like that it is freshly baked. Another sign is an irresistibly buttery crust that leaves you wanting more. Moreover, the top apple pies are perfectly sized for every occasion. They are also made with a one-of-a-kind recipe that is unmatched by every other baker. Finally, look for a pie with filling in every bite. Look for these signs to guarantee that you have found the best apple pie in NJ.